{
  "candidates": [
    {
      "attacks": [
        {
          "attack": "valid_handshake",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_roundtrip",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "replay",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "downgrade",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "invalid_signature",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "handshake_tamper",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "simulated_mitm",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "public_key_substitution",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "identity_separation",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_modification",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "relay_plaintext_absence",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "recipient_node_compromise",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "Expected content exposure after compromise of the authorized recipient",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "future_receiving_key_compromise",
          "expected": false,
          "explanation": "One synthetic next-key experiment. Erasure and full forward secrecy remain unverified",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": false,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        }
      ],
      "candidate": {
        "bind_negotiation": true,
        "generation": 0,
        "id": "strict-baseline",
        "intentional_weakness": null,
        "profile": "strict",
        "replay_protection": true,
        "rotate_kem": false,
        "schema": "cde-protocol/1",
        "suite": "ML-KEM-1024/ML-DSA-87/AES-256-GCM/HKDF-SHA3-512",
        "synthetic_only": true
      },
      "selected_by_functional_controls": true
    },
    {
      "attacks": [
        {
          "attack": "valid_handshake",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_roundtrip",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "replay",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": false,
          "observed": false,
          "status": "FALSIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "downgrade",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "invalid_signature",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "handshake_tamper",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "simulated_mitm",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "public_key_substitution",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "identity_separation",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_modification",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "relay_plaintext_absence",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "recipient_node_compromise",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "Expected content exposure after compromise of the authorized recipient",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "future_receiving_key_compromise",
          "expected": false,
          "explanation": "One synthetic next-key experiment. Erasure and full forward secrecy remain unverified",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": false,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        }
      ],
      "candidate": {
        "bind_negotiation": true,
        "generation": 0,
        "id": "mutant-replay",
        "intentional_weakness": "replay check removed",
        "profile": "strict",
        "replay_protection": false,
        "rotate_kem": false,
        "schema": "cde-protocol/1",
        "suite": "ML-KEM-1024/ML-DSA-87/AES-256-GCM/HKDF-SHA3-512",
        "synthetic_only": true
      },
      "selected_by_functional_controls": false
    },
    {
      "attacks": [
        {
          "attack": "valid_handshake",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_roundtrip",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "replay",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "downgrade",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": false,
          "observed": false,
          "status": "FALSIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "invalid_signature",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "handshake_tamper",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "simulated_mitm",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "public_key_substitution",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "identity_separation",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_modification",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "relay_plaintext_absence",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "recipient_node_compromise",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "Expected content exposure after compromise of the authorized recipient",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "future_receiving_key_compromise",
          "expected": false,
          "explanation": "One synthetic next-key experiment. Erasure and full forward secrecy remain unverified",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": false,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        }
      ],
      "candidate": {
        "bind_negotiation": false,
        "generation": 0,
        "id": "mutant-negotiation",
        "intentional_weakness": "negotiation omitted from authentication",
        "profile": "strict",
        "replay_protection": true,
        "rotate_kem": false,
        "schema": "cde-protocol/1",
        "suite": "ML-KEM-1024/ML-DSA-87/AES-256-GCM/HKDF-SHA3-512",
        "synthetic_only": true
      },
      "selected_by_functional_controls": false
    },
    {
      "attacks": [
        {
          "attack": "valid_handshake",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_roundtrip",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "replay",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "downgrade",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "invalid_signature",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "handshake_tamper",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "simulated_mitm",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "public_key_substitution",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "identity_separation",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "message_modification",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "relay_plaintext_absence",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "recipient_node_compromise",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "Expected content exposure after compromise of the authorized recipient",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        },
        {
          "attack": "future_receiving_key_compromise",
          "expected": true,
          "explanation": "One synthetic next-key experiment. Erasure and full forward secrecy remain unverified",
          "functional_expectation_matched": true,
          "observed": true,
          "status": "NOT_VERIFIED"
        }
      ],
      "candidate": {
        "bind_negotiation": true,
        "generation": 1,
        "id": "strict-ephemeral",
        "intentional_weakness": null,
        "profile": "strict",
        "replay_protection": true,
        "rotate_kem": true,
        "schema": "cde-protocol/1",
        "suite": "ML-KEM-1024/ML-DSA-87/AES-256-GCM/HKDF-SHA3-512",
        "synthetic_only": true
      },
      "selected_by_functional_controls": true
    }
  ],
  "experiment": "CDE-001",
  "formal_scope": "Two-delivery replay transition only",
  "limits": [
    "Complete protocol computational security NOT_VERIFIED",
    "Physical iPhone NOT_VERIFIED",
    "2036 break cost UNKNOWN"
  ],
  "reproduction": true,
  "schema": "security-lab/public-report/1",
  "summary": {
    "acvp": 100,
    "candidates": 4,
    "completion": "completed_experimental",
    "computational_security": "NOT_VERIFIED",
    "date": "2026-11-11",
    "formal_models": 0,
    "hqc_kat": 0,
    "id": "CDE-001",
    "quantum_2036": "UNKNOWN",
    "report": "/security-lab/reports/CDE-001.json",
    "status": "NOT_VERIFIED",
    "tests": 94
  }
}
