Study context
Problem addressed Can a small controlled example verify that known findings are reported?
Contribution relative to existing methods Injected defects make the expected findings explicit and traceable to the underlying analyzers.
Potential commercial use Use the fixture to check the reporting pipeline during onboarding. Market context and value assumptions on the engine page
ESAE · DEMO
Experiment conclusions The analyzers detected all four seeded defects in the controlled case: an out-of-bounds access, a null dereference, an uninitialized value and a memory leak.
Study limits. The test covers the prepared cases only. It does not quantify detection on other programs or verify races, worst-case timing or target hardware behavior.
Scan dd545378-9458-4fe4-b8e7-3f25e41188bc 2026-11-05T22:04:05.210230+00:00 · demo · completed
10 captured source files · 106 physical lines · 1.315 s
{
"static_findings": 11,
"heuristic_indicators": 11,
"ai_explanations": 1,
"static_by_severity": {
"high": 3,
"medium": 4,
"low": 4,
"info": 0
},
"total_findings": 22
} Tool-reported diagnostics require engineering review. Heuristics are risk indicators. AI text is an unverified hypothesis. No source modification, hardware execution or certification.
Example analysis data · JSON
Executed tools and configuration {
"configuration": {
"excludes": [
".git",
".venv",
"node_modules",
"build",
"dist",
"vendor",
"third_party",
"external",
"generated",
".local",
".toolchain"
],
"per_process_timeout_seconds": 30,
"clang_checks": "-*,clang-analyzer-*,bugprone-sizeof-expression,bugprone-infinite-loop,bugprone-suspicious-memset-usage,bugprone-narrowing-conversions,cert-err34-c,portability-*",
"source_mode": "private_readonly_snapshot",
"network": "denied_to_analyzers",
"platform": "Darwin",
"os_sandbox": true,
"ai": "optional_explicit_local_only",
"host_system_headers": true,
"database_used": true,
"accepted_translation_units": 6,
"ignored_compilation_arguments": []
},
"executed": [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"translation_units": 6,
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.109,
"version": "Cppcheck 2.22.0"
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/comm.c",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.331,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/data.c",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.113,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/diagnostics.c",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.112,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/main.c",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.112,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.113,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"file": "src/resource.cpp",
"returncode": 0,
"duration_seconds": 0.382,
"version": "LLVM (http://llvm.org/):\n LLVM version 23.1.4\n Optimized build."
}
]
} Analysis errors and coverage limitations Findings heuristic_indicator / medium
include/sensor.h:5 Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.
esae-heuristics · embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic",
"message": "Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"expression": "uint16_t sensor_average(const uint16_t *values, unsigned count);"
}
}
] static_analysis / low
src/data.c:4 Variable 'values' can be declared as const array
cppcheck · constVariable · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "constVariable",
"message": "Variable 'values' can be declared as const array",
"severity": "low",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "style",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 4,
"info": "Variable 'values' can be declared as const array"
}
]
}
}
] static_analysis / medium
src/data.c:5 Out of bound access to memory after the end of 'values'
clang-tidy · clang-analyzer-security.ArrayBound · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"rule_id": "clang-analyzer-security.ArrayBound",
"message": "Out of bound access to memory after the end of 'values'",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_level": "Warning",
"notes": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Access of 'values' at index 4, while it holds only 4 'int' elements"
}
],
"suggested_replacements_not_applied": 0
}
}
] static_analysis / high
src/data.c:5 Array 'values[4]' accessed at index 4, which is out of bounds.
cppcheck · arrayIndexOutOfBounds · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "arrayIndexOutOfBounds",
"message": "Array 'values[4]' accessed at index 4, which is out of bounds.",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "error",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 5,
"info": "Array index out of bounds"
}
]
}
}
] static_analysis / low
src/data.c:8 Variable 'value' can be declared as pointer to const
cppcheck · constVariablePointer · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "constVariablePointer",
"message": "Variable 'value' can be declared as pointer to const",
"severity": "low",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "style",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 8,
"info": "Variable 'value' can be declared as pointer to const"
}
]
}
}
] static_analysis / medium
src/data.c:9 Dereference of null pointer (loaded from variable 'value')
clang-tidy · clang-analyzer-core.NullDereference · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"rule_id": "clang-analyzer-core.NullDereference",
"message": "Dereference of null pointer (loaded from variable 'value')",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_level": "Warning",
"notes": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "'value' initialized to a null pointer value"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Dereference of null pointer (loaded from variable 'value')"
}
],
"suggested_replacements_not_applied": 0
}
}
] AI hypothesis — not verified {
"status": "generated",
"confidence_type": "ai_hypothesis",
"verification_status": "not_verified",
"finding_id": "1a58addd70213ebd5f673fb6",
"model": "qwen3:4b",
"fields": {
"explanation": "Il tool rileva un accesso a puntatore nullo nel file src/data.c, linea 9, dove viene tentato di dereferenziare un puntatore 'value' inizializzato a 0.",
"possible_causes": "Il puntatore 'value' è stato inizializzato a 0 senza essere allocato dinamicamente o inizializzato correttamente.",
"plausible_consequences": "L'accesso a puntatore nullo può causare crash del programma o comportamenti non prevedibili.",
"suggested_changes": "Inizializzare il puntatore 'value' con un valore valido o verificare se è nullo prima di dereferenziarlo.",
"change_impact": "Il cambiamento riduce il rischio di crash e migliora la sicurezza del codice.",
"verification_tests": "Eseguire test unitari per confermare che il puntatore non è nullo prima dell'accesso."
}
} static_analysis / high
src/data.c:9 Null pointer dereference: value
cppcheck · nullPointer · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "nullPointer",
"message": "Null pointer dereference: value",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "error",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 9,
"info": "Null pointer dereference"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 8,
"info": "Assignment 'value=0', assigned value is 0"
}
]
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/data.c:12 Dynamic allocation via malloc; review failure handling, lifetime and determinism.
esae-heuristics · embedded.dynamic-allocation · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.dynamic-allocation",
"message": "Dynamic allocation via malloc; review failure handling, lifetime and determinism.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"function": "data_leak",
"call": "malloc"
}
}
] static_analysis / high
src/data.c:15 Memory leak: buffer
cppcheck · memleak · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "memleak",
"message": "Memory leak: buffer",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "error",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"line": 15,
"info": ""
}
]
}
},
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"rule_id": "clang-analyzer-unix.Malloc",
"message": "Potential leak of memory pointed to by 'buffer'",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_level": "Warning",
"notes": [
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Memory is allocated"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Assuming 'buffer' is not equal to null"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "'buffer' is not equal to null"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Taking true branch"
},
{
"file": "src/data.c",
"message": "Potential leak of memory pointed to by 'buffer'"
}
],
"suggested_replacements_not_applied": 0
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/diagnostics.c:5 Global volatile object may be shared with interrupts/tasks. Volatile does not prove synchronization or a race.
esae-heuristics · embedded.shared-volatile-candidate · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.shared-volatile-candidate",
"message": "Global volatile object may be shared with interrupts/tasks. Volatile does not prove synchronization or a race.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"symbol": "shared_samples",
"scope": "lexically global",
"race_condition_verified": false
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/diagnostics.c:6 File-local call-name cycle involving diagnostics_retry; review stack depth and termination.
esae-heuristics · embedded.recursion-candidate · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.recursion-candidate",
"message": "File-local call-name cycle involving diagnostics_retry; review stack depth and termination.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"function": "diagnostics_retry",
"resolution": "lexical names, not AST; macros/overloads can invalidate inference"
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/diagnostics.c:11 Dynamic allocation via malloc; review failure handling, lifetime and determinism.
esae-heuristics · embedded.dynamic-allocation · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.dynamic-allocation",
"message": "Dynamic allocation via malloc; review failure handling, lifetime and determinism.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"function": "Sensor_IRQHandler",
"call": "malloc"
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / high
src/diagnostics.c:11 malloc in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.
esae-heuristics · embedded.isr-suspicious-call · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.isr-suspicious-call",
"message": "malloc in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"function": "Sensor_IRQHandler",
"call": "malloc",
"isr_evidence": "function naming convention only"
}
}
] static_analysis / low
src/diagnostics.c:11 Variable 'scratch' is allocated memory that is never used.
cppcheck · unusedAllocatedMemory · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "unusedAllocatedMemory",
"message": "Variable 'scratch' is allocated memory that is never used.",
"severity": "low",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "style",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/diagnostics.c",
"line": 11,
"info": ""
}
]
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / high
src/diagnostics.c:12 usleep in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.
esae-heuristics · embedded.isr-suspicious-call · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.isr-suspicious-call",
"message": "usleep in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"function": "Sensor_IRQHandler",
"call": "usleep",
"isr_evidence": "function naming convention only"
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/diagnostics.c:12 usleep may block; timing depends on platform and arguments.
esae-heuristics · embedded.possibly-blocking-call · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.possibly-blocking-call",
"message": "usleep may block; timing depends on platform and arguments.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"function": "Sensor_IRQHandler",
"call": "usleep"
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / high
src/diagnostics.c:14 free in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.
esae-heuristics · embedded.isr-suspicious-call · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.isr-suspicious-call",
"message": "free in ISR-named function Sensor_IRQHandler; confirm ISR role and target constraints.",
"severity": "high",
"evidence": {
"function": "Sensor_IRQHandler",
"call": "free",
"isr_evidence": "function naming convention only"
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/diagnostics.c:20 Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.
esae-heuristics · embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic",
"message": "Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"expression": "uint8_t result = a + b;"
}
}
] static_analysis / low
src/main.c:6 Variable 'samples' can be declared as const array
cppcheck · constVariable · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "constVariable",
"message": "Variable 'samples' can be declared as const array",
"severity": "low",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "style",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/main.c",
"line": 6,
"info": "Variable 'samples' can be declared as const array"
}
]
}
}
] heuristic_indicator / medium
src/sensor.c:3 Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.
esae-heuristics · embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic · requires_engineering_review
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "esae-heuristics",
"rule_id": "embedded.narrow-integer-arithmetic",
"message": "Arithmetic assigned to a narrow integer: range/conversion risk candidate, not a proven overflow.",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"expression": "uint16_t)(100U + (channel % 4U) * 10U);"
}
}
] static_analysis / medium
src/sensor.c:14 Undefined or garbage value returned to caller
clang-tidy · clang-analyzer-core.uninitialized.UndefReturn · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "clang-tidy",
"rule_id": "clang-analyzer-core.uninitialized.UndefReturn",
"message": "Undefined or garbage value returned to caller",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_level": "Warning",
"notes": [
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"message": "'sample' declared without an initial value"
},
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"message": "Assuming 'ready' is 0"
},
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"message": "Taking false branch"
},
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"message": "Undefined or garbage value returned to caller"
}
],
"suggested_replacements_not_applied": 0
}
}
] static_analysis / medium
src/sensor.c:14 Uninitialized variable: sample
cppcheck · uninitvar · reported_by_tool_not_manually_verified
Evidence / all tool reports [
{
"tool": "cppcheck",
"rule_id": "uninitvar",
"message": "Uninitialized variable: sample",
"severity": "medium",
"evidence": {
"analyzer_severity": "warning",
"inconclusive": false,
"trace": [
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"line": 14,
"info": ""
},
{
"file": "src/sensor.c",
"line": 13,
"info": "Assuming condition is false"
}
]
}
}
] Not verified Worst-Case Execution Time (WCET) Absence of race conditions Functional correctness on hardware MISRA, CERT, DO-178C, ISO 26262 or other standard compliance/certification Absence of all defects/security vulnerabilities Complete call graph or AST-based dataflow